Chelsea's Grocery Run Now Splits Between Eighth Avenue and Chelsea Market

A canvas grocery tote with kale and a baguette beside pears and wrapped cheese on a charcoal counter in a softly lit Chelsea loft.

Two FIT students walked out of the new Lidl at 335 Eighth Avenue in October and told Chelsea News that they had "seen it under construction for a very long time." They were right. The store opened on Wednesday, October 7, but its place on that block was settled in the spring of 2023, when a co-op board made a low-cost supermarket a condition of the deal.

A dozen blocks south, the other end of the neighborhood's grocery run changed in September. Inside Chelsea Market, a butcher became a grocery, and a cheese shop founded in 1892 reopened after closing in Little Italy in March 2023. The two avenues now do two different grocery jobs.

The Supermarket a Co-op Board Asked For

The Lidl sits between West 26th and West 27th Streets, at the base of a seven-story, 188-unit building developed by MAG Partners. The land belonged to the board of the neighboring housing cooperative. Commercial Observer reported in May 2023 that MAG's deal with the board required it to find a low-cost supermarket for the retail space, and that Lidl met that requirement.

The cooperative is Penn South, whose 15 buildings run between Eighth and Ninth Avenues from 23rd to 29th Streets, according to MAG Partners. The supermarket on its Eighth Avenue frontage was a term of the deal. The supermarket on its Eighth Avenue frontage was a term of the deal, set down three years before the store opened.

The building it replaced had held a McDonald's, a Gristedes supermarket and Taco Bandito. The timeline from there:

  1. May 2023. Lidl signs a 15-year lease at 335 Eighth Avenue, with an opening then planned for 2025.
  2. October 2023. Work starts on the site, and MAG says the project should be finished in 2025.
  3. October 7, 2026. The store opens, about a year later than first planned.

Chelsea News counts it as Lidl's fourth Manhattan store. The chain also has a store at 2187 Frederick Douglass Boulevard in Harlem, and its Lower East Side store at 408 Grand Street opened on August 1, 2025.

What the Eighth Avenue Basket Holds

Lidl describes the Chelsea store as more than 12,100 square feet. It carries produce, meat, pantry staples and international items, has an in-store bakery, and rotates nonfood deals through the week. Lidl lists its hours as 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. every day.

Most of the early reaction was about price. The same two students told Chelsea News they found a $3 bag of tortilla chips that they said usually costs at least $5, and Chobani flip cups for under $2. One of them reacted to the bread aisle:

"Two dollars for a loaf of bread? This is crazy! Everything was super cheap."

Another shopper told the paper that dairy items like milk and yogurt cost around $3 to $4. A third pointed out the section of Hispanic foods. Store manager Brayan Garcia said in a statement that the store aims for "a fast, effortless shopping experience."

That covers the weekly staples. The specialty side of a Chelsea grocery run changed during the same weeks, a dozen blocks south on Ninth Avenue.

A Cheese Shop From 1892, Rebuilt Inside Chelsea Market

Pina Alleva, an Italian immigrant, founded Alleva Dairy in 1892, and it ran for generations at Mulberry and Grand. Time Out New York called it the oldest cheese shop in the U.S. when it reported the planned Chelsea Market comeback in December 2025. The Little Italy shop closed on March 1, 2023. Chelsea News reported at the time that the next stop was planned for Lyndhurst, New Jersey.

Instead, the shop reopened on Sunday, September 13, 2026, at Chelsea Market, 75 Ninth Avenue. Owner Karen King brought back the Italian deli foods and the mozzarella made fresh every day, Eater NY reported. King, now the sole owner of the brand, is working with chef Danny Paolucci. She told Time Out that Chelsea Market's mix of cultures and community made it the right place for the shop's next chapter.

Other businesses in the building made the same kind of move this year, from somewhere to eat toward somewhere to shop.

The Butcher That Became a Grocery

Jake Dickson opened Dickson's Farmstand Meats in 2008. In mid-September, the week Eater NY covered on September 18, the Chelsea Market shop expanded into a grocery. Next to the whole-animal butcher counter it now sells locally sourced produce, pantry staples, prepared foods and specialty products. Eater listed items from Pickle Guys and Burlap & Barrel, collaborations with Davey's Ice Cream, and fresh juices, smoothies and salads.

Dickson's now sells most of a dinner, so a resident can buy the meat, the vegetables and the spices at one counter. Alleva sells the cheese and deli items. Hoi An, a Vietnamese sandwich shop from Daniel Le of Essex Pearl and Steven Wong of Aqua Best, joined the market's directory on September 16. It serves bánh mì, rolls and salads. Muji started the trend in January 2025 when it opened its first U.S. Muji Food Market inside its Chelsea Market store. It sells onigiri, egg sandwiches, curry bowls, pastries and pantry snacks.

How the Run Splits Now

The two ends of the neighborhood now do different jobs. Eighth Avenue near 26th Street handles the weekly basket at discount prices. The Ninth Avenue end, around the market, handles the items people go out of their way for.

Stop Where What it adds Open since
Lidl 335 Eighth Avenue, West 26th to 27th Discount staples, bakery, rotating nonfood deals; 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. daily October 7, 2026
Dickson's Farmstand Meats Chelsea Market Butcher counter plus produce, pantry and prepared foods Grocery expansion, September 2026
Alleva Dairy Chelsea Market, 75 Ninth Avenue Daily-made mozzarella, Italian deli foods September 13, 2026
Hoi An Chelsea Market Bánh mì, rolls, salads September 16, 2026
Muji Food Market Inside Muji, Chelsea Market Onigiri, curry bowls, pantry snacks January 2025

The Saturday Market Has a Closing Date

The outdoor part of the run follows the season. The Down to Earth Chelsea Farmers Market sets up on the north sidewalk of West 23rd Street just off Ninth Avenue, Saturdays from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. Its 2026 season ends December 19. After that, the closest Saturday market is the Abingdon Square Greenmarket at Hudson Street and Eighth Avenue, just south of Chelsea. GrowNYC runs it all year, Saturdays from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m.

Chelsea Market's events calendar also lists a Dickson's Holiday Extravaganza on December 10. That evening falls after the butcher counter became a grocery and before the farmers market closes for the season.

On Eighth Avenue, the supermarket Penn South's board required is now open every day from 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. Around Ninth, a cheese shop founded in 1892 is making mozzarella every day again, a few doors from a butcher that now sells pickles and produce.

Carol knows from long experience how far a co-op board's decisions can reach beyond its own lobby. Penn South's supermarket requirement shaped a whole avenue's grocery options. If you are weighing how a building's board, its commercial frontage or its block will affect a sale or a purchase in Chelsea, Carol Staab will walk you through it in person. Work With Carol.

Work With Carol

Carol Staab has an innovative luxury real estate practice that provides an elite level of concierge service through unparalleled world-class marketing and a hands-on business approach. Her mission is to give her clients an exceptional experience while helping them achieve the best results possible.